Guide to the Best Bakeries in Middleton, Wisconsin

On a chilly Wisconsin morning, there’s nothing like the warm, inviting atmosphere of the neighborhood bakery to get your croissant and hot chocolate. Middleton, Wisconsin is home to some of the best local bakeries, serving up fresh coffee alongside decadent coffeecakes, donuts, homemade pies, and chocolate treats to please the most persistent sweet tooth! Take a walk through historical Middleton for the area’s best local bakeries, and enjoy some fine home-baked goods now, or later!

In true European fashion, Clasen’s European Bakery on 7610 Donna Drive offers you the best bets for all the classics. From chocolate-filled croissants, French éclairs, homemade donuts, and fresh coffee, this family-owned bakery features over 300 different bakery products displayed in beautiful glass cases. You’ll feel like a child in a candy store again; be sure to pick up a cupcake or two for dessert later in the evening! Call (608) 831-2032 to arrange for any special orders or customized cakes.

Scott’s Pastry Shoppe is a Madison and Middleton favorite, offering a wide selection of wedding cakes, cookies, pies, bread, and pastries. Serving the local area for over 21 yars, Scott’s also serves up some lunch sandwiches and soup. Since there’s always room for dessert, be sure to try out the oversized Chocolate Chip cookies that melt in your mouth; the Old-Fashioned Sour Cream donuts are a hit year round, so get in before 7 a.m. for the freshest batch! Scott’s Pastry Shoppe is located at 6637 University Avenue, and orders can be called in at (608) 836-7333.

For the neighborhood café experience, stop into the Prairie Café & Bakery on 6720 Frank Lloyd Wright Avneue. This friendly café serves breakfast and lunch every day, and includes all your breakfast classics from pancakes, to waffles, to French toast. Enjoy from the made-from-scratch bakery selections including muffins, donuts, and bear claws. You’re sure to find something for every taste! Call (608) 827-2437 for lunch or dinner reservations.

Head over to C’s Restaurant, Bakery and Coffee Shop at 2550 Allen Boulevard for the best selections in muffins, donuts, and homemade pies. C’s is a popular spot for the neighborhood breakfast too, and is open at 6 a.m. all week, and 7 a.m. on Sundays. Call (608) 836-4700 for daily specials.

For some of the area’s best pastries, espresso, and biscotti from a variety of local bakeries, stop into Barrique’s at 1901 Cayuga Street. The Cowboy Cookies are a must-try, and will curb any chocolate addiction immediately. Enjoy the selection of locally-roasted coffee and espresso with your choice of baked treat, and discover the world of gourmet desserts for your own after-dinner specialty.

Middleton, Wisconsin features plenty of opportunities to indulge that sweet tooth with some of the area’s best made-from-scratch bakery options. Head over to the neighborhood to take care of that sugar craving!